Should you put all your money into Bitcoin at once, or buy a fixed amount every month? The question comes up constantly, and the answers are usually opinions. As a data analyst, I wanted the actual numbers, so I tested every monthly start date in the Bitcoin price history I use for the Bitcoin DCA calculator.
How the test works
- Data: monthly closing prices of BTC/USDT on Binance, from August 2017 to September 2026 (110 months).
- DCA: buy $100 of Bitcoin at every monthly close.
- Lump sum: invest the same total amount at the first monthly close, all at once.
- Both are valued at the same later date. Fees are ignored because they are small and the same for both approaches.
This is a simplified backtest. Real buys happen on different days and prices, but monthly closes are enough to see the pattern.
Result 1: by start year, held until September 2026
Here is what happened if you started in January of each year and kept going until the end of September 2026, when Bitcoin closed at $83,624.
| Start | Total invested | DCA value | Lump sum value | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 2018 | $10,500 | $54,132 | $85,371 | Lump sum |
| Jan 2019 | $9,300 | $38,795 | $226,464 | Lump sum |
| Jan 2020 | $8,100 | $22,913 | $72,422 | Lump sum |
| Jan 2021 | $6,900 | $13,412 | $17,436 | Lump sum |
| Jan 2022 | $5,700 | $11,189 | $12,391 | Lump sum |
| Jan 2023 | $4,500 | $7,082 | $16,273 | Lump sum |
| Jan 2024 | $3,300 | $3,618 | $6,481 | Lump sum |
| Jan 2025 | $2,100 | $2,075 | $1,714 | DCA |
Lump sum wins most rows, sometimes by a lot. Starting in January 2019, putting everything in at once would have been worth almost six times more than spreading it out. The reason is simple: over most of this period Bitcoin went up, and money invested earlier had more time in the market.
Result 2: every possible start month
Start years can be misleading, because January is just one month. So I also tested every possible starting month and measured each approach over a fixed holding period. A 12-month test, for example, compares $100 a month for 12 months against $1,200 invested on day one, both measured 12 months after the start. That gives 98 different start months for the 12-month test, 86 for 24 months and 74 for 36 months.
| Holding period | Lump sum won | Median return DCA / lump | Worst return DCA / lump |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 months | 61% | +26% / +43% | -53% / -73% |
| 24 months | 70% | +61% / +103% | -50% / -52% |
| 36 months | 72% | +99% / +161% | -9% / +5% |
Two things stand out:
- Lump sum wins more often, in roughly 61% to 72% of start months depending on the period, and its typical (median) result is higher.
- DCA has much smaller bad outcomes. In the worst 12-month period, DCA was down 53% while lump sum was down 73%.
This matches research on stocks: lump sum tends to win because markets rise more often than they fall, but DCA reduces the damage when you start at a bad moment.
The bad timing test: November 2021
The best way to see what DCA protects you from is to start at a top. Bitcoin closed November 2021 at $56,951, near its peak at the time, and then fell for a year.
Start: November 2021, invested until September 2026 ($5,900 in total)
DCA, $100 a month: $11,517
Lump sum, all at once at the top: $8,663
Here DCA clearly won, because it kept buying through the 2022 crash at much lower prices. The reverse happens when you start at a bottom: from November 2022, when Bitcoin closed at $17,164, the same $4,700 grew to $8,075 with DCA but to $22,899 as a lump sum.
Nobody knows in advance whether they are buying at a top or a bottom. That uncertainty is the real reason DCA exists.
So which one should you choose?
The data doesn't pick a winner for you, but it does make the trade-off clear:
- Lump sum has the better average result in a rising market, but you have to live with the risk of a 50% to 70% drop right after you buy.
- DCA gives up some average return in exchange for a smoother ride and much better worst cases.
- For most people the question is theoretical. If you invest from your salary, you are already doing DCA, because the money arrives monthly.
The most useful question is often: if Bitcoin fell 60% the month after you invested everything, would you hold or panic sell? If the honest answer is "sell", DCA is probably the better fit, because a strategy you can stick to beats a better strategy you abandon.
Try your own dates
The Bitcoin DCA calculator uses the same price data. Pick any start and end month and any monthly amount to see how your own DCA plan would have done, including a year-by-year table.
If you already buy every month, the average price calculator shows your real average entry across all your purchases.
This analysis uses historical monthly closing prices and ignores fees, taxes and exact purchase timing. Past performance does not predict future results. This is educational content, not investment advice.